Wednesday, October 2, 2024

DEI Corrupts

 

I received subscribed emails from Chris Rufo, the bright, principled, young conservative thinker and journalist. I enclose his entire 6/29/24 email to me and then will comment where appropriate.

 

 

 

Rufo: “How DEI Corrupts America’s Universities

Christopher F. Rufo <rufo@substack.com>

Sat, Jun 29, 7:01 AM




 

to me





Forwarded this email? Subscribe here for more

How DEI Corrupts America’s Universities

The ideology of “diversity, equity, and inclusion” is not what it purports to be.

Christopher F. Rufo

Jun 29

A person with a beard

Description automatically generated

 

 

 




 

 

 







The idea of public universities in the United States originally rested on a compact between the citizen and the republic. The agreement was that the citizen would provide funding for the university in order to train young people to advance the public interest and the common good. In recent years, however, this compact has shattered, and considerable efforts will be needed to rebuild it.”

 

My response: Like hesitant Rufo critic, Jordan Peterson, recently suggested, it is concerning that conservatives activists like Rufo are politically inserting themselves in the process of running universities, a needed correction to offset the corrupt, ideological excesses of DEI promoted there by staff and professors; Peterson worries that right-wing ideologues running campuses with intellectual purity tests would be no improvement on left-wing ideologues currently terrorizing and suppressing intellectual dissidents at campuses across America.

Rufo, denies this criticism because he claims conservatives becoming regents and curbing woke ideological tyranny on campus will not go overboard, because they want balance in views, not control and conformity, and I believe Rufo.

Second, Rufo does seem to offer a historical basis for the idea that public universities here originally rested on a compact between the citizen and the republic. The citizens fund the universities so colleges and professors will train the young, and this advanced the public interest and the common good. Rufo is angry that Leftist postmodernists have shattered this compact, and considerable efforts are necessary to rebuild it.

I think Rufo should be unleashed to show what he can do to improve a university, and I have not forgotten Peterson’s warning.

I would offer my solution that if each 18 year-old is an individuating supercitizen on the way and in training to assume her adult role, no professor, no ideologue, no institution will be strong enough or cruel enough to make her submit to their brainwashing and mind control. Her powerful original thinking, her force of personality, and her indomitable courage will render it impossible to force her to sumbit to their threats and bullying. This is the best corrective prevention to any institutional attempt anywhere—including colleges-to tyrannize and mind-control the students or the young, the favorite target for ambitious authoritarians.

 

Rufo: “The clearest expression of what has gone wrong is DEI. At first glance, a commitment to “diversity, equity, and inclusion” might seem laudable. But DEI employs a propagandistic language to conceal its real intentions. It is, in fact, the opposite of what it appears to be.”

My response: DEI is propagandistic language pushed by postmodernist true believers to capture and control all free young people at college.

 

Rufo: “We can review the acronym in parts. First, “diversity.” The initial connotation of the word suggests a variety of people, experiences, and knowledge. But in practice, universities use diversity to justify a policy of sometimes explicit, sometimes implicit, racial discrimination: a total inversion of the principles of colorblind equality and individual merit.”

My response: Diversity for Progressives means monolithic sameness of viewpoint, and there are no individuals: their policy of reverse discrimination inverts the principles of colorblind equality and individual merit, as all people are avatars of their intersectionally assigned group memberships, favoring some groups and putting down other groups: these are cruel people with evil intentions towards those disfavored by them.

Rufo: “Second, “inclusion.” In kindergarten, teaching kids to be inclusive means encouraging them to share and be polite to classmates. But in the context of a university, inclusion is used as justification for excluding people and ideas that are seen as a threat to prevailing ideologies and sentiments.”

 

My response: For Leftists inclusion does not mean inclusion: it means radical excluding of people, ideas and disfavored group members viewed as antithetical to the prevailing ideology and sentiment of Leftists. 

Rufo: “Finally, “equity.” The immediate association is with the principle of equality. But equity is actually a radically opposed idea. Equality is the principle that every man or woman should be judged as an individual, neither punished nor rewarded based on ancestry. Equity demands the opposite: categorizing individuals into group identities and assigning disparate treatment to members of those groups, seeking to “equalize” what would otherwise be considered unjust outcomes.

What this means in practice is that members of certain groups get favored, others disfavored: in short, inequality justified under the ideology of “equity.” “

 

My response: I cannot improve on his definition of equity. Postmodernist Marxist equity is actually pure inequity, pure inequality, pure injustice visited upon disfavored groups like males, whites, Christians, Jews, conservatives, individualists, Americans, capitalists and heterosexuals, by those now running the institution and their favored groups elevated above the disfavored groups, a naked display of reverse discrimination unfolding.

 

Rufo: “You see this hiding in plain sight. Universities publish in their own materials prima facie evidence of their commitments to racial discrimination, quotas, and disparate treatment on the basis of identity in hiring, admissions, promotions, and in other programs.

Administrators, who are supposed to administer services and manage programs neutrally, use DEI ideology to impose political criteria on the speech and behavior of faculty, students, and staff. They subordinate the pursuit of truth, which should be a university’s highest commitment, to the dogmas of ideological activism.”

 

My response: Again, Rufo incomparably and simply reveals how DEI ideology in practice is the imposition of totalitarian practices, employed in Red China or in modern Russia, upon once open, free liberal arts colleges. DEI advocates have critically and perhaps irreversibly damaged our universities. Rufo’s modest but powerful of reasonable public retaking of that university in Florida is critically needed, despite Jordan Peterson’s worries of Rufo and his ilk going to far.

Rufo: “To give an example of how DEI is actually practiced, consider the following training materials from University of Colorado Boulder’s DEI program.

The basic predicate of CU Boulder’s DEI program is that “Black, Indigenous and People of Color,” or “BIPOC,” students are failing because of “white supremacy culture.”

What is white supremacy culture? According to CU Boulder’s DEI documentation, it includes “individualism,” “perfectionism,” “a sense of urgency,” “worship of the written word,” and “objectivity.” These traits are supposedly vestiges of “whiteness” and unavailable to racial minorities—an unintentionally bigoted attitude. 

Next, CU Boulder’s DEI bureaucrats would have you engage in a 21-day “Racial Equity Habit Building Challenge.”

One of the resources included in this program is a guide on “How to Be a Better White Person.” The document supplied a protocol on how to accomplish this task. Step one: “Realize you’re white.” Step two: “Recognize your privilege.” Step three: “Know things.” Finally, from a related resource, instructions on how to be an “ally” to racial minorities: “Transfer the benefits of your privilege to those who lack it”; “amplify the voices of the oppressed before your own”; “acknowledge that, even though you feel pain, the conversation is not about you.”  

This is not the language of an academic program but of an abusive relationship.”

My response: These cultural Marxist fanatics are sick, vicious, and could lead to murderous persecution of targeted groups. Pol Pot would have been proud of their attempts.

Rufo: “Unfortunately, the language of DEI has also taken hold in CU Boulder’s curriculum. For example, the university has recently included a course on “Critical Whiteness Studies.” The syllabus is replete with activist terms, such as “institutionalized whiteness,” “white privilege,” and “white fragility.” The basic concept is that “whiteness” is an irreducibly malicious essence, loaded with ancestral guilt.

Human history is brutal and filled with injustice. But to scapegoat one population group, European whites, as the essence of evil is nothing but propaganda. Obviously, none of this meets any genuine scholarly standards—and that’s a pattern characteristic of DEI.”

 

My response: To scapegoat onto European whites is to make us the new Jews, and these lying blood liberlists will put whites in chains and mark them for death camps in 2077 (if they go forward unchecked) like the Nazis did to Jews in the 30s and 40s.

Rufo: “Finally, DEI is used as a justification to hire scholars of favored demographics and ideologies. CU Boulder has explicit and implicit racial quotas in hiring, which, in theory, violate the law. According to one professor, more than 90 percent of recent hires at CU Boulder’s College of Arts and Sciences have been diversity hires. Of the remaining 10 percent, some might lay claim to other protected identities, such as “LGBTQ,” reducing the percentage of “oppressors” even further.

This is unethical and immoral. But under DEI, it is a requirement of social justice.

The problem with DEI is not merely administrative or curricular. When its principles are adopted wholesale, DEI compromises the fundamental purpose of the university and the basic compact between the citizen and the state.

In fact, the degeneration of universities into centers of ideological activism—which American taxpayers are currently subsidizing—violates basic democratic principle to such an extraordinary degree that we urgently need to implement dramatic reforms.”

My response: I am pleased that Rufo understands the problem and how to make it better.

Rufo: “Fortunately, this is now beginning to happen. We have already abolished or curtailed DEI bureaucracies in 12 states. In Florida, where I have worked on the reform campaign, Governor Ron DeSantis has not only abolished DEI but also enacted reforms to faculty hiring, university governance, and the core curriculum.

The vision for these reforms is simple: to prioritize merit over ancestry, and to govern by the principle of colorblind equality, rather than left-wing racialism. The university should judge everyone as an individual, rather than as avatars of the “oppressor” and the “oppressed.” “

My response: One is not civilized, moral or just unless one judges everyone as individuals, based in their merited treatment under the umbrella of colorblind equality. Each person is a sovereign individual, and no more must group identity allow people to be mendaciously reduced to being group representatives as groupists, belonging to condemned, attacked oppressor groups, against the favored, elevated oppressed groups, now the new elite, now granted special privileges, to made permanent.

Rufo: “And, most of all, the university should be oriented toward truth. In the coming years, state leaders will have to choose: to prioritize the pursuit of knowledge, or to prioritize racial activism.

We can encourage genuine diversity—a range of opinion, from a variety of people—but universities under DEI have demonstrated, time and again, a basic hostility to scholarly standards and fair conduct. 

America’s universities have been a boon to our society. They deserve public support. But only if the universities meet their end of the bargain.

Abolish DEI. Restore merit. And let the universities pursue their true mission, without ideological interference.

That is what we are working toward. And we will win.

Christopher F. Rufo is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Subscribed

This article was originally published in City Journal. “


Tuesday, October 1, 2024

The Counter-Elite

 

I am quite impressed with the brilliance, wonderful articulateness, and grasp of the latest conservative thinking, captured by Chris Rufo, in all that he writes. I am older than him by at least 30 years, and my radical reclusiveness leaves me vulnerable to becoming stale and hackneyed in my thinking, because I have become severed from the marketplace of current ideas being exchanged. Following Rufo is one way for me to mitigate the effects of being isolated.

 

I agree with him 90% of the time, but a few months ago, I wrote how he is traditional and elitist in one respect. He worries rightly about the current cultural domination of all corporations, institutions, and government agencies by the cultural Marxists, that the ruling elite here is corrupt, totalitarian and addicted to power, a sickness that that eaten all the way through them. They are now rotten, cruel, wicked, stupid, arrogant people out to fundamentally finish the transformation/ruination of America, a most undesirable end which is imminent unless the conservative masses and a few conservative intellectuals are able to obviate the grandiose, destruction vision of the Progressives, mainly by electing Trump to a second term.

 

Rufo is one of the young conservative intellectuals leading the charge against the ravaging attack of the rabid Left, and he and his ilk have enjoyed some success.

 

Then he wrote an article that deeply offended and alarmed me: I became convinced that he is deeply mistaken and his reforms at best will restore America to its Enlightenment condition as a free market constitutional republic with a culture predicated on Judeo-Christian/Greek values,and the first principle that the sovereignty of the individual to think as he will for himself as a rational free agent.

 

I think Rufo believes that to restore America to its former greatness and its conservative, Western heritage, it requires the unified allegiance and joint sponsorship of that counter-revolution by a newly minted conservative, cultural, business, and political elite to run things.

 

I enthusiastically support the reform, but I believe in the masses, the people, the way that current elitist intellectuals like Rufo and Jordan Peterson do not.

 

It is my basic assumption that every human being is loaded and blessed with near infinite intelligence (regardless of the gradations of IQ difference lived by people—as individuators anyone can unlock more IQ from his mind to be smarter than he is right now), will, energy, courage and talent to self-realize as a living angel, as an individuating supercitizen, as such fit to live in America and make the laws that she will obey, and to run the country by consent and programmed fabricated and agreed to by the masses informally.

 

It is the masses that will complete the conservative counter-revolution, and maintain it, and they need no elite, no hierarchy, no sprawling institutions of any kind (limit all institutions in size, scope, and reach, not just going for limited government) to tell them how to live, how to conduct themselves, and give them orders.

 

Rufo is suggesting that a new elite be formed to run things and direct the masses once the counter-revolution is victorious, and his implication is that the masses will go back to sleep, become indifferent, drift back into a way of life dominated by hierarchies, and destructive collectivist policies. As groupist, nonindividuating, altruistic group-livers that group-identify, they are what Rufo worries that they actually are and will return to being; such naughty adult children require elites to run things for them, which is fine as long as the elite is not entrenched and corrupted by centralize power, which eventually happens, and then the masses suffer mightily as abused, enslaved, oppressed and exploited victims of the ruling elite. The nonindividuating masses, as second-handers, are always re-enslaved.

 

That unenlightened masses require elites to rule them is the fault of the elite nearly as much as it is the fault of each of the masses for failing to assert herself and allow none to enslave her, and none to do her thinking for her.

 

To be ruled by elites on the Right, eventually and inevitably leads to fascism, monarchy, or strong-man dictatorship.

 

To be ruled by elites on the Left eventually and inevitably leads to Communism or mob-rule.

 

The people always suffer needlessly when elites run things. Better morally elite citizens to run things while part-elite, and part-common person.

 

With this introduction finished, let me now share all of Chris Rufo’s email with the reader as I respond to it where needed.

 

 

Rufo: “

 

 

J. D. Vance and the Emerging Counter-Elite

How a second Trump administration could avoid some of the pitfalls of the first.

Christopher F. Rufo

Jul 27, 2024

 

Former president Donald Trump’s selection of Ohio senator J. D. Vance as his running mate has generated much commentary. The mainstream media has tried to frame Vance as a postliberal “threat to democracy,” while Trump’s supporters have celebrated him as a bridge to a new generation.

But there is a deeper story here. The Vance selection is not a gambit to secure a particular demographic or region—white men are Trump’s base; Ohio is a safe red state—but an effort to cultivate an emerging counter-elite that could make the second Trump administration substantially more effective than the first.

This story is built into J. D. Vance’s biographical arc. He was the all-American kid who rose from humble beginnings to make his way in the world: the Marines; Yale Law; venture capital; a best-selling book. He learned the language of the prestige institutions, cultivated powerful patrons, and quickly climbed the ladder in academia, finance, and business. He had made it.”

 

My response: I like Vance a lot, and all that Rufo says about him is fair and accurate. Then, Rufo takes the plunge: The Vance selection is an intelligent step made by Trump to cultivate an emerging counter-elite to make the new Trump administration more effective.

Rufo is limited in his thinking in that he is reforming universities, and he is limited in his understanding and vision as he touts the new Vance-included conservative counter-elite to run the reconstituted American dream under Trump II Administration, should that come about.

The problem is always the individual, and that is the conclusion one must reach as an advocate of egoist morality, accepting that it is self-evident that the individual is  sovereign over all things.

The individual must self-realize and run all institutions as well as his personal affairs if society is to survive, function and flourish. Were 85% of the masses to maverize as individuating supercitizens, and they will eventually, once they learn how to live and behave optimally under Mavellonialist ethical instruction, the each citizen thinks and acts as an elite person would, while still being a commoner so democratically dispersed power-sharing arrangements prevent elites from forming and to be corrupted by power, which they then abused to bring injustice, malevolence and suffering to bear on all society, upon all the poor, subjugated citizens.

 

Rufo: “Then, his story takes a turn. Having entered the ranks of America’s elite, Vance became disillusioned and disenchanted with it, correctly identifying it as a force of hypocrisy and corruption. He defected—first, by parting ways with the respectable conservatism of the Beltway, and then by embracing Donald Trump.

 

Some have criticized this as a cynical move, but my sense is that it is the opposite. A cynic would have continued to build an elite résumé; Vance sacrificed his respectability within a certain stratum, assumed considerable risk by moving toward Trump, and, in my view, was genuinely convinced that the establishment, both Left and Right, had exhausted itself and had to be opposed.

Now, not only has Vance been selected as a vice-presidential nominee; more significantly, he has charted the path for an emerging new conservative counter-elite.”

 

My response: Rufo is very, very sharp. He is right to be the first to state that Vance is emerging as a leader, perhaps the leader of the surfacing counter-elite Right, and that Vance is so standing out of principle, not an opportunistic grab for power.

What Vance and the emerging conservative counter-elite require—where will Rufo fit in as a potential political player in this new regime?—is the maverized, supercitizenized masses to direct them, and tell them how to govern—to obey or to be replaced.

 

Rufo: “The political balance is beginning to shift. A significant cohort of power brokers in Silicon Valley and on Wall Street have publicly moved toward Trump in this election cycle. Some of the names are familiar: Elon Musk, Marc Andreessen, David Sacks, Bill Ackman. But hundreds of other influential figures are assembling behind the scenes to support Trump’s campaign. Even some of Trump’s former adversaries, such as Mark Zuckerberg, have expressed cautious admiration for the former president.

Vance can now position himself at the center of this counter-elite. He has been in the boardrooms, made the pitches, and built the relationships. He speaks their language. They can do business together.

This could represent a sea-change. During the first Trump administration, especially following the death of George Floyd, institutional elites could neither express admiration for nor devote public support to Trump without paying a significant political price. Now the market has shifted, with a dissident elite moving along a similar path as Vance.”

 

My response: Again, Rufo is extremely bright to anticipate what will happen, and what should happen. I just wish Mavellonialism was better known, more popular and accepted, so we could reform our citizens, to make the wonderful American Way a permanent restoration.

 

Rufo: “Signals in these institutions always flow from the top down. When the All-In podcast members host a fundraiser for Trump, they give permission to others in Silicon Valley to do the same. When Bill Ackman endorses Trump without negative repercussions, he gives permission to others on Wall Street to speak their minds.

If the Trump-Vance ticket wins in November, this counter-elite support could pay significant dividends for the Trump agenda.”

 

My response: In my ideal constitutional republic, free marketed and brimming with feisty, organized, engaged and willful individuating supercitizens, no longer will institutional signals flow from the top down, as they always have. The maverized Americans masses will force all leaders and institutional functionaries to obey and step lively, as things will be signaled and sent from the bottom up for the first time in human history, a cultural and civilization-forging transformation of marvelous potential.

 

Rufo: “In his first administration, Trump led through charismatic authority, trusting his intuitions and using the force of his personality to bend policy from the White House. There were successes but also limitations. Trump endured considerable staff turnover, often lacking the institutional buy-in that would enable him to implement his agenda effectively. This is not a problem that Democrats face; their institutional strength is immense. For a Republican president, however, a supportive counter-elite has become an essential precondition for success.

This is where Vance can help with Trump’s agenda. He can serve as a translator, turning Trump’s charismatic vision into a rational-legalistic formula. And he can lead the emerging right-wing counter-elite, so that Trump’s policies, which enjoy a significant base of support among the working and middle classes, can gain greater traction within elite institutions.

We should note the irony. Trump’s childhood was gilded, while Vance’s was troubled. And yet, Trump has a magnetic attachment to the masses—think of his archetypal Rust Belt voter—while Vance holds appeal to a sector of the elite. For this reason, Trump’s picking Vance makes sense. He saw not only someone who could help advance the agenda but also a younger heir who could bring it into the future. 

In this way, it is a more ambitious gesture than typical VP picks by either party, which are more commonly driven by a need for “balance” on a ticket. If Trump wins in November, and Vance is able to form a durable counter-elite, Trump’s selection of him could prove to be one of the most consequential vice presidential choices in modern history.”

 

My response: Yes, Trump by himself is a charismatic flash-in-the-pan which the Deep State will resist and outlast without a conservative counter-elite to give the reform depth. However, the conservative counter-elite desperately requires 225 million anarchist individuating supercitizens to set them straight and keep them on the straight and narrow politically. This is real reform, perhaps the last political reform required.

 

Rufo is prophetic and an original thinker. What he sees in J.D. Vance seems realistic. I just wish Rufo was versed in Mavellonialist philosophy so he could take his conservative reforms to the next and perhaps ultimate level of reform, the liberation of each citizen. I conceive of myself as a Prometheus-type, hoping to provide humans with the fire of egoist ethics, so they can stay warm and cook their food.

 

Rufo: “Christopher F. Rufo is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Top of Form

Bottom of Form

Top of Form

Bottom of Form

This article was originally published in City Journal.”

 

 

Monday, September 30, 2024

The Response

 

I have for two years subscribed to an online email delivery written by journalist and thinker Chris Rufo. Below I copied out his entire article, A Response to Jordan Peterson. I will comment periodically on Rufo’s article.

 

Rufo: “

A Response to Jordan Peterson

The distinguished psychologist is wrong about the politics of the university.

 

Christopher F. Rufo

Aug 29, 2024

The Canadian psychologist Jordan Peterson is perhaps the most famous academic dissident in the world, having made his reputation opposing the ideological corruption of the universities. And yet, when considering practical reforms, he is stricken with doubt.

In a recent episode of his podcast, Peterson hailed me as a “very effective counter-propagandist” against academic corruption and, in particular, for my successful campaign to oust Harvard’s president, Claudine Gay. But alongside this praise, Peterson expressed concern, even opposition, to my work as a trustee at New College of Florida, where I have helped abolish DEI, terminate the gender-studies program, and establish a new classical liberal arts curriculum.

“The DeSantis administration, along with Rufo, are making moves to implement a certain degree of political control over the content of at least one university in Florida. And that would mean that there would be one new conservative university compared to 99 percent of the radical leftist universities,” Peterson said. “And the danger is that the political starts to explicitly permeate the educational. And you could say the leftists walked right into that because of their insistence that the ideological permeates the educational. But it still doesn’t look to me like that excuses the potential for an equivalent error on the more conservative side.” “

 

My response: Peterson has a point, but I think Rufo is largely fair and nuanced, and I do not think political conservatives will become fascist forcing conquered colleges to conform to newly introduced right-wing ideology, like we just suffered when politically extemists left-wing ideologues dominated and dominate our educational institutions.

 

Peterson offers a needed cautionary reminded, that the government need not be running universities, and I want all students to be individuating supercitizens, for such powerful individuals of incisive intellect, indomitable will and powerful self-advocacy, will not long tolerate any institution educational or otherwise, to dictate to them, and this is the best protection against political elites running universities in inappropriate ways that Peterson worries about.

Rufo: “I will respond to these objections in three parts.

First, Peterson implies that “political control” over universities is illegitimate. It is not. New College of Florida is a public university, and public universities are the creation of the state—that is, they belong to and should reflect the values of the public. In Florida, voters elect their representatives, who, in turn, charter, fund, and govern the public universities. The takeover of New College was, in this manner, an expression of the democratic will, moving the public university in line with the wishes of the public.

It was always this way. When Thomas Jefferson wrote the charter for the University of Virginia, one of the first public universities in the United States, he explicitly stated that the university should promote the virtues of the broader society and that the ultimate authority rested with the legislature. The university’s leadership, he insisted, “should at all times conform to such laws as the legislature may from time to time think proper to enact for their government, and the said University should, in all things, and at all times be subject to the controul of the legislature.”

As Jefferson might remind Peterson, the alternative to “political control” of the universities is not enlightened self-government but bureaucratic rule. The laissez-faire attitude of legislators, who, in recent decades, ceded control of the public universities to unelected administrators and faculty departments, created the precise problem we are now trying to resolve. It is not a betrayal of classical liberal values to insist that political leaders, rather than permanent bureaucrats, govern public institutions—it is, rather, a restoration of those values.

Second, Peterson is concerned that creating a “new conservative university,” as he characterizes New College of Florida, could represent “an equivalent error on the more conservative side” to that made by “radical leftist universities.” No: The equivalent error would be to propose that conservatives rule all of the universities, systemically exclude progressives from faculty positions, and use academia as a vehicle for political activism. We have done nothing of the sort. We have, instead, created a balanced faculty, fostered debate, and revived classical liberal principles at the state’s smallest university—not an equivalence in degree or in kind.

I would interrogate Peterson’s position a step further. Does he believe that the status quo of left-wing domination is somehow more legitimate than our reforms? Does he think that Florida voters, who elected Governor DeSantis in a landslide and whose taxes bankroll public universities, should be denied a public education system that represents their values? Why should they be compelled to subsidize DEI and gender studies rather than the classical liberal arts?

Third, Peterson warns that the ideological should not permeate the educational. On this, I would agree, but with a twist: America’s public universities are too ideological, but insufficiently political. In other words, we should absolutely reject the status quo of activist pseudo-scholarship and cheap left-wing partisanship, but we should remember—and embrace—the fact that public universities are inherently political institutions, with a duty to promote citizenship, cultivate virtue, and pursue the public good. It is not by accident that Aristotle’s theory of education appears in the final book of the Politics.

Jefferson concurred. The imperative of the public university, he insisted, is to educate the young, and, in particular, the leadership class, into the political regime. He envisioned America’s universities as a place “[t]o form the statesmen, legislators, and judges on whom public prosperity and individual happiness are so much to depend.” And he saw clearly that this would require strong leadership, able to maintain the republican character and transmit political knowledge from one generation to the next.

This brings me to my final point: prudence. Peterson is intimately familiar with the crisis of the academy. Yet, he hesitates to embrace even the most modest reform. He apparently prefers the posture of the critic and, as a result and perhaps inadvertently, defends the status quo. This is regrettable. The prudent line of action, consistent with the principles of classical liberalism—not to be mistaken for non-interventionism—is to support reforms that restore public trust, rebalance the faculty, and reorient the universities toward truth, rather than power.

The universities are in a grave state of disrepair. The time for action is now. Anything less is an abdication.”

 

My response: I agree with Rufo more than Peterson.

 

Rufo: “Christopher F. Rufo is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Top of Form

Bottom of Form

Top of Form

Bottom of Form

This article was originally published in City Journal.”

 

 

 

Academic Reform

 

I have for two years subscribed to an online email delivery written by journalist and thinker Chris Rufo. Below I copied out his entire article, The Difficult Work of Academic Reform, which I received on 9/3/24, and which I will periodically comment on.

 

Rufo: “

 

Christopher Rufo

The Difficult Work of Academic Reform

New College of Florida enters its second year under new leadership.

 

Christopher F. Rufo

Sep 03, 2024

 

A small public university on the coast of Sarasota, New College of Florida spent decades languishing as a left-wing activist haven. Its enrollment, test scores, and other measures steadily fell. Legislators in Tallahassee considered closing it.

Then suddenly, the school was in the news. In January 2023, Governor Ron DeSantis appointed a slate of new trustees, including me, to the New College board and tasked us with transforming the institution into a “classical liberal arts university.” “

 

My response: Most colleges and universities in America, public or private, have become bastions of cultural Marxism and stifling wokeness, mediocrity, and intellectual conformity. Students overwhelmingly have become groupist, true-believers, activists promoting the mass movement, Communist postmodernism. Why are the taxpayers funding professors and Academy clerisy who wish to overthrow, deconstruct, and remake America fundamentally.

 

Rufo teaches at Hillsdale college, a beacon of hope and academic sanity in the modern world. It still is the classic liberal arts university which needs to be restored so students are taught critical thinking, now to think and speak for themselves as independent individuals, and they are to be  taught content not social justice ideology.

 

Rufo’s goal is worthy.

Rufo: “The media covered the event in dramatic style, with more than 1,000 stories targeting the college and its new leadership. We had drawn attention, but what was our plan for reform?

“Soldiers win battles,” an old military adage holds, “but logistics wins wars.” The same is true in universities. Political leaders can replace a board of trustees, select a new president, and unveil a vision for change. But the fate of any such project lies in the detailed work of administration: the thousands of small decisions that affect the culture of the university.

This is where we are now with New College. In the first year, we engineered our revolution: deposing the existing leadership, abolishing the DEI department, terminating the gender-studies program, and announcing a vision for transforming the institution. Now we are pursuing the hard work of reform. Under the leadership of President Richard Corcoran, we are making progress along three tracks: faculty hiring, curriculum design, and student recruiting.

First, faculty hiring. In year one, we witnessed unprecedented faculty turnover. Approximately 40 percent of existing faculty left the institution through resignation, nonrenewal, and other incentives. The press treated this as a failure— “exodus,” “chaos,” “brain drain,” read the headlines—but each departure created an opening for a better replacement.

This work is imminent. We expect soon to announce the hiring of up to 40 new professors, all sharing a commitment to the classical liberal arts. While we are careful to avoid partisan language, we freely admit that, in practice, this means that the faculty as a whole will shift rightward.

This should be celebrated. We will have the most balanced faculty of any state institution in Florida, with a wider range of opinion than our competitors. And we will have a strong contingent of faculty members who reflect the basic philosophical commitments of the people of Florida, who, it should be noted, generously fund our operation.

Second, as we welcome new faculty, we can begin to design the curriculum for all four years. Last term, President Corcoran announced the basic structure of the new curriculum, balancing the concepts of logos and techne, beginning with a mandatory humanities course on Homer’s Odyssey and continuing with courses in the applied arts, statistics, and data science.

This year, I hope to see the full elaboration of our core curriculum, with courses in the philosophy, history, science, and arts of the West. We hope to recruit a permanent provost with the pedagogical sophistication to design the curriculum and the professional network to recruit the faculty who will teach it.

New College has the opportunity to create a curriculum on par with our private-sector counterparts, such as Hillsdale College, and to demonstrate that public universities don’t have to succumb to left-wing ideological capture. With sufficient political will, they can govern themselves on a different set of principles entirely.

Finally, student recruiting. In the first year, President Corcoran organized a near-miracle. In a matter of months, he recruited the largest incoming class in New College’s history, without the benefit of a full admissions staff or a normal application cycle. He demonstrated to the legislature that, despite the churn, New College was growing.

The next step is to improve student culture and competitiveness. Each year, the number of students who matriculated here under the previous administration declines, while the number of students who entered under the current administration grows. The result is a gradual recomposition of the culture.

We believe that New College can be a destination for Florida families who value the Western tradition and that it will provide continuity for students with private, home-based, and religious high school backgrounds, in addition to those who have graduated from public institutions. Classical education, in particular, is the fastest-growing pedagogical approach in K–12 schools; we hope to earn the trust of those families as they consider their college choice.

In time, we hope that New College develops into the best classical institution of its kind, while also disproving the assumption that public universities must submit to DEI bureaucracies, grievance departments, and other left-wing staples. We want to demonstrate instead that the public—the voters of Florida, who express themselves through their elected representatives—rules public institutions.

Anything less will reflect a serious failure of leadership.

Christopher F. Rufo is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

This article was originally published in City Journal”

 

My response: Well done. The reader knows that I want each person to self-realize and self-educate for a lifetime, mostly as an amateur, and this strong individualist emphasis comes close to making the reform of any institution of education an almost irrelevant factor.

Censorship

 

I subscribe to emails sent me by Chris Rufo, the conservative thinker and journalist. He sent me an email on 9/10/24, entitled, ‘What’s At Stake in the Censorship War—The fight for a free internet is raging globally.’

 

I will quote his entire email below, and comment on in paragraph by paragraph, or as I read something that invites comment, interpretation, or reaction.

 

 

 

Rufo: “The censorship war has hit a flashpoint. Late last month, Brazil banned Elon Musk’s social media site, X, after Musk refused a government order to suppress seven dissident accounts. Brazilian Supreme Court justice Alexandre de Moraes responded by restricting access to the platform across the country. This story has direct implications in Brazil and also reveals the hidden stakes of the global censorship war.

One way to measure the influence of a political regime is to trace the flow of money, goods, people, information, and force. These are the raw materials of politics, and the form that these materials take helps to shape the form of the political regime.

When the Cold War ended, many Western elites invested their hopes in the “open society”: a global system of democracies that ensured the free transmission of trade, capital, migration, and data, with limited use of force. But this system, which seemed to be consolidating through the world, was challenged by the rise of right-wing populist parties in Europe, Latin America, and elsewhere—including in the United States.”

 

My response: We need a world of individuating supercitizens, and that requires an internet, and all other media platforms, no matter if impartial, leftist or right-leaning, be unfettered utterly with no government interference ever in the name of curtailing or suppressing hate speech, misinformation, disinformation, or dissenting speech of any kind.

Individuators are radically independent thinkers, and free speech is vital to free thinking, and free thinking rewards individualist insight so beneficial to a free society.

Rufo: “Elites responded by cracking down on right-wing voices to prop up the progressive status quo. In Brazil, for example, the government wants to restrict the flow of right-wing opinion, which dominates on X, so that it can solidify support for its left-wing government. For opponents of right-wing populism, controlling the flow of information is critical because it influences the flow of all other goods. If you cannot freely transmit information, you cannot shape political life.

The Brazil conflict reveals that the crucial locus of resistance to the consolidation of the “open society”—in reality, a system of left-wing hegemony—is technology. Prior to Musk’s takeover of X, governments had developed a working relationship with the major social media platforms, which were, through incentives and aligned interests, restricting the speech of conservative journalists, activists, and political figures, including that of a sitting president, Donald Trump.

Musk, however, has disrupted this consensus not only by purchasing the most important social media platform but also by exposing the collusion between the government and the company’s previous leadership to censor political opinion. And he has refused to bow to foreign governments’ demands of further content moderation.”

 

My response: Citizens everywhere must make it crystal clear to their elites and governors that censoring political opinion will not be tolerated anywhere by any ruling tyrant or elite, and any effort to install such censorship and stifling of dissent is a legitimate reason to rise up and violently overthrow the government.

Rufo: “This battle is being fought around the world. In the United States, a heated conflict over censorship, disinformation, and free speech rages on. In England, the police are shutting down speech and arresting citizens who publish disfavored opinions online. The European Union has passed the Digital Services Act, which will further restrict the range of opinion under the guise of “fighting disinformation.” And like Brazil, other nations have blocked certain platforms entirely.

Suppressing dissent is the ultimate goal. Elite opinion around the world is remarkably consistent; the rise of populist ideologies, formulated and disseminated online, has become a major threat to these elites’ worldview and power.”

My response: Suppressing dissent is the ultimate goal. Elites everywhere do not want right-wing masses or the populace of populists to think, write and exchange views on the internet that may be antithetical to worldview and power of elites.

 

It is time for the masses everywhere to rise up and insist by force and arms, if necessary, that tyrants and elites will no longer be allowed to suppress free speech and free idea exchange anywhere.

 

 

Rufo: “What comes next? Conservatives in Brazil and elsewhere fear that pro-censorship institutions will move from soft to hard power—that they will “dismantle democracy to save democracy.” We can see this transition in real time, from soft versions of censorship, such as politically motivated fact-checking, to more aggressive means, such as restricting the accounts of dissidents, to the most extreme form: arrest and expropriation, which has already become a reality in countries such as England and Brazil.

The bottom line is that Elon Musk’s fight for a free and open Internet is our fight. It is critical to preserve at least one platform capable of resisting the transnational consolidation of power and the censorship of its ideological enemies. We must fight to win, not only in Brazil, but everywhere. This means supporting Musk’s X and resisting draconian censorship laws wherever they emerge. The coming months and years will be decisive.

Christopher Rufo is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

This article was originally published in City Journal.”

My response: I agree.

Sunday, September 29, 2024

Immigration

 

I subscribe to emails received from reporter Chris Rufo. He sent me his article on Immigration on 9/25/24. I quote all of his article and will comment where need be. The title of his article is: The Real Question of the Immigration Debate.

 

Rufo: “Political campaigns are symbolic ventures, designed to drive attention to certain issues and marshal facts, language, and emotion to deliver a material advantage. From Cicero’s campaign for the consulship to Kamala Harris and Donald Trump’s campaigns for the presidency, it has always been thus.”

 

My response: If the candidate is ethical, sensible, competent, honest, and not overly mendacious or manipulative, and she offers the public an explicit, tangible agenda which aims to see fulfilled, then her political campaign as a symbolic venture is acceptable, for rituals, symbols and narratives provide people with meaning and cultural order.

 

If the voters were individuating supercitizens, they will relay to politicians that the facts, language, and emotion marshaled to deliver an advantage to a campaign, had better be a clear plan that actually is good for the people and the country. No more lies, no more excuses, no more hidden agendas, no more going to Washington get rich as a supporter of the Swamp.

 

Rufo: “This is a useful lens through which to view the current immigration debate. For several weeks, two-migrant related stories have dominated national attention: Venezuelan gang members apparently seizing apartments in Aurora, Colorado, and tensions resulting from large-scale Haitian migration in Springfield, Ohio. Beneath the surface of their rhetorical heat, the controversies pint to three questions of immigration policy: who, how, and how much.”

 

My response: Immigration should be sparing, limited, legal and enforced with illegal aliens sent home, or, if some stay, they are never allowed to become citizens and vote. Americans need closed, walled, enforced borders; America is for Americans, and it is a privilege to live here, and a privilege to immigrate here. We want immigrants, few in number, but that are patriotic, willing to assimilate completely into American culture as it is, and to learn English and be self-support and living legally.

 

Rufo: “Let’s be clear away some misconceptions. Both Trump and Harris’s stated views on immigration—which may not, of course, reflect their actual views—are more nuanced than commonly portrayed. In 2021, Harris warned illegal immigrants that ‘if you come to our border, you will be turned back,’ acknowledging, at least rhetorically that Americans have the right to decide who enters the country. Likewise, Trump, despite his restrictionist reputation, often interleaves calls to ‘build the wall’ with appeals to build a ‘beautiful door.’ In other words, between the candidates, the questions of who, how and how much are ordinal, rather than categorical.

 

The first and most controversial of those questions is ‘who.’ Progressives believe that human beings are interchangeable, and that all differences are socially constructed and ultimately arbitrary. At first glance, this position seems grounded in the theory of natural right encapsulated in the Declaration of Independence’s famous phrase ‘all men are created equal.’

 

My response: Largely, under natural right theory, all men or humans are created equal, so in theory an immigrant could come from any foreign country. Yes, in theory all people are interchangeable, but context is everything. All humans, instinctually are embedded in or would default accept living under a dispensation which is socialist, altruistic, groupist, non-Western and usually accepting of authoritarian homeland rule. People do not like themselves, and usually elect to be abused slaves, no matter where they hail from.

 

We need to be hyper-picky about whom we let in: they can be anyone from anywhere, as long as they conform to and eagerly seek to conform with American mainline values, culture, and politico-economic wonder of free market constitutional republicanism.

 

This best country that the world has ever seen should not allow very many foreigners ever to immigrate, and only those that mesh with our way of life. If not, they are refused entry. If they cheated and came here illegally, they are sent home.

 

Rufo: “But this ignores a critical distinction. Yes, all men are born equal—that is, they are all born with the same human fundamentals—but this does not imply that all cultures, or civilizations are equal. Among the principles that cultures adopt and inculcate in their members, some are better, others are worse; some are compatible with America’s traditions, some are not. For American immigration policy, this means that the ‘who’ matters.”

 

My response: I agree with this entire paragraph. The solution to protect America by very selective, with actually restrictive immigration enforcement. We need to work with foreign governments so they can move towards constitutional republicanism, free market economics, and adopting American values and culture, to make things so opportunistic, free, and prosperous at home, that immigrants really have no desire to come to America, because America is coming to them, and they can blend Americanism with their native ways at home, as they see fit.

 

Rufo: “The question of ‘who’ has historically involved considering migrants’ national origin. A more refined approach would include other characteristics, such as educational attainment, employment history, language skills, and cultural values. The United States, which has an interest in admitting immigrants capable of integration and economic productivity, is well within its rights to prefer, say, an English-speaking software developer from Venezuela over a violent, uneducated gang member from the same country.

 

On the same principle, we must acknowledge that immigrants from some cultures are more capable than others of assimilating to America.”

 

My response: It is not that some are more able to assimilate to America than others; rather many recent immigrants feel their culture and values are distinct from, even superior to American values and culture, and some ever seek to replace the American value system with a foreign hostile set of values, say set up shariah law and a caliphate all across America. If immigrant applicants, refuse to assimilate, they should be sent home, or not allowed in in the first place.

 

Rufo: “In much of the Muslim world, for example, majorities believe that honor killings are justified and that Sharia law ought to be enforced by the state. While many Muslim immigrants embrace Western values, some emphatically reject them, as demonstrated by the widespread pro-Hamas protests that have broken out in the aftermath of the October 7 massacre in Israel. Pluralism is valuable, but it has limits, and America ought to select newcomers who shared its core values.”

 

My response: If potential immigrants do not share core Western and American values, then they should not be admitted. Pluralism and multiculturalism are of limited value, and they can stay home and practice their cultural and value mores.

 

Rufo: “The next question is ‘how.’ The answer is not to be found at our southern border today, which has become an anarchic, free-for-all zone. While there will always be some degree of undocumented migration—the United States is, after all, still the land of opportunity—the numbers we have seen in recent years are unprecedented. Americans have the right to insist on a rational, orderly process of immigration, with clearly defined standards and a carefully crafted selection process.

 

The final question is ‘how much.’ To answer this, one must consider not only the sheer number of immigrants but also the amount of migration-driven demographic change occurring over time. Both the absolute size and pace of recent immigration give America to be more cautious in the recent moment, despite our unique ability to assimilate newcomers. Both that scale and speed of recent immigration—some 8 million new arrivals since Joe Biden’s presidency began—is putting enormous pressure on each level of government. Localities have struggled to meet surging demand for housing, medical care, and education, particularly given the proportion of migrants with limited earning potential and English language proficiency.

 

The debate in Springfield, Ohio is relevant here. There is a material difference between assimilating 150 Haitian migrants and 15,000 Haitian migrants into the fabric of a small town. The former is easily done; the second represents a transformative challenge. And progressive ideology, which discourages integration into the national culture and claims that assimilation is a form of racism, colonialism, and xenophobia. As the left reorients our institutions away from assimilation and toward multiculturalism, our capacity to immigrate newcomers will continue to degrade.”

 

My response: If an American was to immigrate to China, Japan, or a Muslim country, would be those countries of intake be tolerant of Western ways being retained by the migrant? Not likely: Americans are the least racist, colonialist, or xenophobic people in the world, so love it or you will not enter it—America, that is. Assimilate or stay home—Progressives, American-haters and often traitors to this greatest nation, be damned.

 

Rufo: “Across the developed world, mass migration is undermining native-born citizens’ quality of life and sparking a global anti-immigration backlash. Instead of insisting that these concerns are racist conspiracy theories, defenders of mass migration would do well to take them seriously.”

 

My response: You never solve a problem by relocating it, say mass forced exodus of the population from a bad neighborhood, or ghetto neighborhood, say, by taking 75,000 out of the 82,000 residents living in the blighted communities (say north Minneapolis and Philips neighborhoods in Minneapolis), and bussing them in 3 days, without notice and them unceremoniously depositing them in affluent, peaceful Woodbury (population: 80, 891 residents), and then ordering that city to absorb them painlessly.

 

I am not being racist, but people in blighted neighborhoods—yes, mostly nonwhite—if they moved enmasse to Woodbury, would destroy Woodbury. You have spread and metastasized the problem not solved it.

 

The cure is to take those 75,000 in north Minneapolis and in Philips neighborhood and introduce them to Mavellonialist values and culture. As individuating supercitzens, they would be model citizens, and in 15 years those inner-city neighborhoods would be as livable, desirable, prosperous and crime-free as they were in 1912 when the Norwegian and Jewish immigrants lived in those neighborhoods.

 

Similarly, to solve the problems of the underdeveloped and Third World nations, mass migration will not solve their problems at home, and will sink the developed nations as predictably as transplanting north Minneapolis and Philips neighborhood in neighborhoods along Interstate 94 in Woodbury.

 

We must limit our immigration to 300,000 people per year for the next ten years, until we are able to stabilize America, and undo the terrible damage intentionally done to America by the vicious Left.

 

The people of Third World countries desperately need democracy, republicanism, capitalism, freedom, law and order, and anti-corruption campaigns and God in their lives. With mass retraining on how to live, if they were interested in reforging themselves, this mass training for the peoples of Third World countries would work wonders for them at home.

 

If they are willing to learn from us, they would go far. For without the right values, the right economics and free, small, limited government, these countries remain hopeless hellholes that have to keep sending or allowing their unfortunate masses to migrate to the developed world, eventually tanking those countries that are functioning and desirable.

 

You do not cure a diseased population by exporting the infected members of the sick society to healthy societies with little of that sickness for spreading sickness will turn all societies into sick societies.

 

Rufo: “The best outcome for the United States, in the closing stretch of a presidential campaign, would be to engage in a real discussion about these questions, which the Left is intent on avoiding. For them, mass migration is a potential source of patronage and votes, best cultivated surreptitiously. But the country at large must grapple with immigration, in all its complexity. The nation’s future depends on it.”

 

My response: The only cure is to declare the American Way is the set of values and culture that are the best in the world, and, when Mavellonialist values and culture are added to, this superior civilization will enable any country, anywhere, and its people of any color or religion, to flourish, be rich, happy, and free.

 

That is the truth, and we must not be shy about stating it openly. Accept us and grow, or reject us and die on the vine, but we will no longer be letting in your millions of suffering, desperate immigrants because the elites running these nations badly cannot, or will not embrace tangible reforms.