Wednesday, September 25, 2024

Nathaniel Branden

 

On Page 37 of Ayn Rand’s book, The Virtue of Selfishness, her follower and collaborator, Nathaniel Branden writes that mental health or self-esteem are identical, the same, synonymous: “Neither mysticism nor the creed of self-sacrifice is compatible with mental health or self-esteem. These doctrines are destructive existentially and psychologically.”

 

Branden like Rand is a secular humanist and believes God and the spiritual world are nonexistent, so he equates mystical faith in God or spirits necessarily leads to low self-esteem, mental illness, and the immoral ethical creed of self-sacrifice which Branden denounces as evil and destructive to human happiness and well-being.

 

Jordan Peterson would go ballistic to have Branden, a psychotherapist and Ph.D. holder, equate mental health is the same as high self-esteem, a view I largely agree with; Peterson would also reject his egoist ethics.

 

Branden continues writes about pride on Pages 39 and 40: “. . . His life and self-esteem require that make take pride in his power to think, pride in his power to live, pride in his power to live—but morality, men are taught, holds pride, and specifically intellectual pride, as the gravest of sins. Virtue begins, men are taught, with humility: with the recognition of helplessness, the smallness, the impotence of one’s mind.”

 

My response: It seems quite evident that Rand and Branden, like I do, regard intellectual pride as man’s cardinal virtue, whereas Peterson dismisses intellectual pride as humanity’s cardinal sin or vice.

 

Branden: “Is man omniscient? –demand the mystics. Is he infallible? Then how dare he challenge the word of God, or of God’s representatives, and set himself up as judge of—anything?”

 

My response: No human is not omniscient and never will be (even if he could be omniscient, he could not stay sane with that kind of thankless responsibility and power for everything; becoming omniscient for humans is an impossibility, and that impossibility is a blessing, for we would be destroyed by such awesome need to rule the world.). Still, we can know a lot and learn a lot as individuators, worshiping good deities, and obedient to these employers. We are not infallible, and the good deities expect, even demand that we question the existing word of God and God’s representatives, so that we can grow in truth and benevolent consciousness in this world and retire to heaven in the next world—as long as we are respectful and courteous while questioning and challenging the existing theological order.

 

We are to judge, but we are not to brag. Final, eternal judgement of people’s souls is not our bailiwick, and is reserved for the good deities to pass judgement and sentence upon all of us at heaven’s gate.

 

Branden: “Intellectual pride is not—as the mystics preposterously imply it to be—a pretense at omniscience or infallibility.”

 

My response: Branden and Rand are humbler than are transhumanists that deny the deities exist, or, if they do, the arrogant transhumanists anticipate humans with their new-found and arriving deity-level personal powers and intelligence, will push old deities aside, or even kill them (an impossibility). Transhumanist can regard themselves as omniscient, infallible, immortal, all-powerful and all-hating; if that self-appraisal is accurate and actual, then these despicable devils are guilty of vicious intellectual prid; they will be overthrown, defeated, and cast into the pits of hell by the angels defending and serving the good deities.

 

 Branden: “On the contrary, because man must struggle for knowledge, precisely because the pursuit of knowledge requires an effort, the men who assume this responsibility properly feel pride.”

 

My response: I agree with Branden that humans intellectually struggle to gain knowledge, and do make some modest progress in each generation, so having worked so hard, they can feel proud of what they have learned, deduced or discovered.

 

Branden: “Sometimes, colloquially, pride is taken to mean a pretense at accomplishments one has not in fact achieved. But the braggart, the boaster, the man who affects virtues he does not possess, is not proud; he has merely chosen the most humiliating way to reveal his humility.”

 

My response: The boaster flaunting his unearned pride is not proud but boasting to mask and suppress his profound personal insecurity, his self-doubt to deny his immense, intense sense of self-loathing.

 

Branden: “Pride is one response to one’s power to achieve values, the pleasure one takes in one’s own efficacy. And it is this that the mystics hold as evil.”

 

My response: One has a right to feel proud if one has good values, and one actually lives them and achieves then efficaciously, and if one is modest in one’s pride in thought, in worship and in public comportment and statement.

 

Branden: “But if doubt, not confidence, is man’s  proper moral state; if self-distrust, not self-reliance, is the proof of his virtue; if fear, not self-esteem, is the mark of perfection; if guilt not pride, is his goal—then mental illness is a moral ideal, the neurotics and psychotics are the highest exponents of morality, and the thinkers, the achievers, are the sinners, those who are too corrupt and too arrogant to seek virtue, and psychological well-being through the belief that they are unfit to exist.”

 

My response: Rand and Branden have a point to make, that doubt, beyond a certain amount, is a lack of self-confidence, conducive with self-hatred and a propensity to sin. The good deities want humans to be confident and proud and accomplished, but never to forget where they come from, who sponsored them, and to whom they owe a bottomless debt of gratitude, devotion, stated appreciation and public acknowledgment of dependency.

 

Branden: “Humility, is, of necessity, the basic virtue of a mystical morality: it is the only virtue possible to men who have renounced the mind.

 

Pride has to be earned; it is the reward of effort and achievement; but to gain the virtue of humility, one has only to abstain from thinking—nothing else is demanded—and one will feel humble quickly enough.”

 

My response: Humility more than not is a vice under godly and secular egoist morality, and pride more than not is a virtue under godly and secular egoist morality.

 

Humility is a virtue under mystic and secular proponents and exponents of altruist morality, and pride is the cardinal vice to these altruists.

 

One is required by the good deities to feel positive or individual pride and to exhibit and practice positive individual humility, while one is to think, use one’s mind, talents, imagination and effort to make oneself self-realized, and, if one has served the good deities and fought the good fight, one can feel justly proud of one’s accomplishments, while ever humble or realistic enough to accept one’s modest improved status and position in the great chain of being among the living angels in league with the departed angels (the Good Spirits), and all are subordinate in rank and power and just pride felt by the individuated and individuating good deities.

 

The Latest

 

Yesterday, briefly, I had a few minutes to listen to Dennis Prager on the radio while eating lunch, and it is a privilege which has been rare for me lately. He is very wise and super-smart. His ethical system is still altruist-egoist, the standard traditional Judeo-Christian and secular humanist morality, pervasive throughout the West, but Prager is leaning towards my morality of egoism-altruism, though he is not aware of the trend, and would likely deny so leaning if I pointed it out to him.

 

Here are some points that he made that show his thinking is progressing from altruist morality, more towards egoist morality.

 

First, he repeated his often-stated case that the bigger the government, the more corrupt it is. This seems like classical conservative philosophy, and it is because centralized power corrupts, and totalitarian government (wholly, purely centralized power over the people economically, politically, legally, and socially) is absolutely corrupt.

 

What interests me is his emphasis on large, centralized government and its intimate, proportionate link to corruptibility increasing as public and private institutions become huge monopolies controlling every aspect of society and the lives of its citizen/victims.

 

If one accepts that individualism and egoism are morally good, and groupism and altruism are evil and morally vicious, then as hierarchies become taller, extending everywhere through society in all institutions, there the helpless, captured masses are stratified and locked into a set of ascending classes with most at the bottom ruled by a few at the top. In a hierarchical society, where personal freedom and equality per capita are denied the masses who also fail to fight for freedom and equality, there depraved human nature that is selfless, group-oriented and altruistic, is further sickened as personal and communal self-hatred is ramped up to new heights.

 

When a wicked people are infected with hatred of self and others, embedded in personal low self-esteem, their country will be a society, this centralized, bureaucratized, hierarchical social order, especially prone to massive corrupt practices and enormous even genocidal human rights abuses because pure, near universal private and public hatred and hating are pure evil, and corruption is evil by another name.

 

 

Second, insightful Prager mourned the ontological fact the liberty is not an instinct but is a value. People by nature are fatalistic and crave to be enslaved, oppressed, and exploited (as a member of the victimizing class, or the majority in the victimized classes); they do not like themselves or others, so being enslaved is how they prefer to live. If big government promises to feed them, pay them, provide for them, and do their thinking for them—if the citizens will agree to forfeit personal liberty to the government, as the exchange paid to authoritarian control by governmental functionaries—that is a bargain the masses are most willing to accept, and even beg for.

 

Only a society of individuating supercitizens, living in something like an America with its free market constitutional republic of limited government, and massive amounts of each supercitizen wielding power, liberty and influence, can have trained a group of upper-middle class citizens (the majority of the country’s population), will insist and demand that their culture and social order be a society where personal liberty, freedom of speech and intellectual independence are pervasive and unlimited. There will the masses possess the self-awareness, the Mavellonialist training and right value system on how to act and how to run a country;  their intact and achieved self-discipline lead them to shout out and demand fulfillment of their preference for liberty to slavery as the red line for no acquisitive politician to cross over.

 

Prager wants limited, small, strong government run by a population of strong, assertive individualist citizens, and this anticipates my concept of the egoist, individuating supercitizen.

 

Third, the Left preaches hate. Nothing is your problem. Your faults, problems and failure are always problems owned by an outsider, or society. Your failure is their fault, not your own. This grows and magnifies citizen envy, anger, resentment and a desire for revenge, retaliation and usurping power for other groups, growing division and hatred and conflict in America: blacks, Muslims, women, LGTBQ, people of color (the “oppressed” noble groups and tribes) set against whites, males, heterosexuals, conservatives, individualists, and Christians (the “evil oppressor groups).

 

Prager does not say it, but I believe that altruism-collectivism as an ethical system deprives everyone of the opportunity, the power and the blessing to be responsible and take control of her own life on her terms and make something of herself, blaming no one else and accepting blame against her from no one else (unless it is corrective, fair criticism to be addressed). If she is a successful individuators, she is not obliged too, nor should be willing to ascribe her astonishing success to others only marginally responsible for her victories.

 

Leftism is a mass movement, and its zealous true-believing adherents are filled with self-hatred and hatred of all other rival groups and unaffiliated individuals, so they wish to inflict maximum harm upon themselves and others, to gain absolute power over them, or even exterminate others from the face of the earth. This is where cultural Marxism is headed to, and they will make Stalin and Hitler look like trial-run choir boys by comparison.

 

When the individuators loves herself and God first, and then, others secondarily, then she blames only herself, and corrects her deficiencies, thus much improving her lot, and then she can be proud of what she has accomplished, and no one gets the credit but herself. Being blamed or praised are both earned by her so there is no need to hate or blame or fight with the neighbors. A society of individualists should be largely peaceful and cooperative with their neighbors because there is little group rivalry, destructive completing or even warring to lead to civil war or unrest.

Thursday, September 19, 2024

Highest Value

 

The dear reader will recognize that this entry is a minor follow-up piece or addition to my 8/26/24 blog piece on pride in reaction to Jordan Peterson’s controversial remarks about pride as the cardinal sin.

 

This entry is a quotation from Ayn Rand’s book, The New Intellectual, a paragraph from Pages 130 and 131, which I will quote in full and then comment on.

 

Rand: “Pride is the recognition of the fact that you are your own highest value and, like all of man’s values, it has to be earned—that of any achievements open to you, the one that makes all others possible is the creation of your own character—that your character, your actions, your desires, your emotions are the products of the premises held by your mind—that as man must produce the physical values he needs to sustain his life, so he must acquire the values of character that make his life worth sustaining—that as man is a being of self-made wealth, so he is a being of self-made soul—and to live requires a sense of self-value, but man who has no automatic values, has no automatic sense of self-esteem and must earn it by shaping his soul in the image of his moral ideal, in the image of Man, the rational being he is born able to create, but must create by choice—that the first precondition of self-esteem is that radiant selfishness of soul which desires the best in all things, in values of matter and spirit, a soul that seeks above all else to achieve its own moral perfection, valuing nothing higher than itself—and the proof of an achieved self-esteem is your soul’s shudder of contempt and rebellion against the role of a sacrificial animal, against the vile impertinence of any creed that proposes to immolate the irreplaceable values which is your consciousness and the incomparable glory which your existence to the blind evasions and the stagnant decay of others.”

 

My response: I am an individualist and want people to be proud of themselves if they are making a living, are ethical, modest, and effectively individuating. I would not, even then, claim that any human, however brilliant and individuated, is her own highest value. She can rate herself plenty high, and that fine and deserved, but the good deities should be her highest value/values, and so represented by her in her own cogitations, as well as so publicly announced.

 

Rand is not for mindless hedonism, or whimsical selfishness: it is implied that she want each person to maverize, and Howard Roark seems to me to be the avatar of the great soul in action. Thus her standard of rational selfishness (I prefer self-interest, a term and concept, which is not loaded with so much notorious baggage as the adjective selfishness.) insists and demands of each maverizer that she is to set up high-quality values for herself, that she is to live up to and according to, and then she will have earned her self-pride, but it must be earned, and, if she later falls backward, she can no longer be proud of how she is living.

 

I repeat, none of this has to do with slighting the good deities or boasting.

 

Rand is correct that acquired fine personal character is built upon a self-conscious, life-long effort and journey, to accrue by one’s own hard work, self-made wealth, and a creative, noble self-made soul.

 

The articulate Rand, above, notes that ‘ . . . automatic values, has no automatic sense of self-esteem and must earn it by shaping his soul in the image of his moral ideal, in the image of Man, the rational being he is born able to create, but must create by choice . . .’ each person is morally obligated and responsible for self-development as a self-actualizer, that she must construct, adopt, and put into action a superior set of values (not instinctively embedded in her consciousness) to live by, and, then, only then will she feel self-esteem and pride in whom she has evolved into being. As such, she deserves praise.

 

 If she continued along the popular, unremarkable lifestyle of the nonindividuated second-hander, living inside of and running with the pack, she is a sinner and rebel against God (my addition, not Rand’s), and is to be rebuked as the sinful, altruistic, selfless slacker that she was born to be, and refuses to grow out of.

 

I would argue that the good deities agree with Rand more than they do not (they want to be worshiped, treated reverently and politely—and given credit for how wonderful they are), want each human to fail to shaper her soul in the image of her moral ideal as life as individuating, rational human, approved of by the individuating self, and approved of by the good deities and their Good Spirits, who also are individuated and individuating, and expect humans to maverize also.

 

Jordan Peterson, in one of his many video clips on Ayn Rand, referred to her as not a first-rate mind. Because he is a considerable, natural genius and a man of high ethical standards, there seems at times, to be an elitist snobbishness oozing out of him. That this little, Russian Jewish woman, an immigrant from Russia, put together from scratch all that she did, seems miraculously brilliant and astonishing to me. No second-rate mind gave us the Randian support for love of liberty, egoist-individualist morality, the pride of place attributed to reasoning over feeling and instincts, capitalism, the need to return to Objectivist ontology and epistemology, her adoration for the American constitutional republic, the accentuation of individualism as the sovereign Western axiom. She is a genius, and being Jewish likely helps: Mark Levin, Ben Shapiro, Dennis Prager, Eric Hoffer were all or likely were all Jewish Americans, and their influence upon me is profound.

 

Peterson needs to understand that individual’s possession of personal goodness and wisdom and self-realized creativity is not necessarily caused by being a genius; being brilliant helps, but, as all humans of differing talent and intelligence maverize, we cannot predict—only God can—who will be the wisest, the more insightful, or the best predictor of how humankind should proceed. We must be humble about not listening to others; God works through them too, and if they maverize, God’s truth comes pouring out in their thoughts and shared words, and Truth comes from mysterious places in unexpected ways.

 

The professional philosophers, so smart and specially educated and credentialed, denounce and revile Rand, the amateur philosopher, but she—not they--gave us Objectivism, rationalism, individualism and capitalism and democracy as the most moral economic and humane political arrangement required for people to thrive.

 

Rand, in the paragraph quoted above, seems to me to offer a vision for individual self-realizing, that is secular humanism at its apex. She and her followers likely and excessively verge over into transhumanism, under which humans seeks to become living, mortal gods, that run their world with no place for devotion to, service towards and bended-knew obedience to the guidance of the ruling good deities.

 

As transhumanists, humans would be guilty of Luciferian intellectual pride which Peterson rightly is railing against. When the good deities have been slighted, ignored, and insulted sufficiently, when they have had enough, they will burn the godless, secular, human civilization to the ground, should it come about.

 

Rand gave us a renewed emphasis on Objectivism, capitalism, love of personal liberty, egoist morality, and a championing of reason, and these are attributes inherent in and intricately intertwined with the actions, character and worldview of the good deities.

 

Of course I do not know, but I do not think Rand is in hell for her transhumanist leanings: she alone, by herself, came up with godly philosophical attributes to emulate and prioritize—though she was an ardent materialist and atheist—and that brings humankind closer to introducing Mavellonialism to the world, and that allows the good deities to be reintroduced to humankind, and for the Good Spirits to take over and rule here on earth.

 

For her services well-rendered, I like to assume that Rand served some time in Purgatory, and then perhaps is existing in some level of heaven.

 

Let me repeat the rest of that quote and then respond to what she wrote: “that the first precondition of self-esteem is that radiant selfishness of soul which desires the best in all things, in values of matter and spirit, a soul that seeks above all else to achieve its own moral perfection, valuing nothing higher than itself—and the proof of an achieved self-esteem is your soul’s shudder of contempt and rebellion against the role of a sacrificial animal, against the vile impertinence of any creed that proposes to immolate the irreplaceable values which is your consciousness and the incomparable glory which your existence to the blind evasions and the stagnant decay of others.”

 

My response: Jordan Peterson would be angered and aghast that I agree with Rand that the first precondition of feeling positively proud and esteeming the self is to express and live that radiant selfishness of soul which desires the best in all things. I would replace the word selfishness with enlightened self-interest, that desires the best in all things for the body and soul, but would value the self highly, but would value the good deities even higher.

 

 

Each individuator that chooses to maverize will be able and empowered to develop a talented, original-thinking consciousness that is self-interest at its finest, and, then, only then, can the self esteem the self.

 

No longer must the human individual sacrifice herself for the sake of the pack, for society, for the ism favored by her tribe, clan, or nation. That historical role of the joined, selfless nonindividuator was to live a life of sin, being in league with and in service to the Dark Couple. No more.

Wednesday, September 18, 2024

Stifled

 

Altruism as an ethics of immorality is evinced most concretely as mobs of joiners, nearby a neighbor that is a great soul, execute an intentional, permanent campaign of obviation against the great soul, the victim of their abuse, their hostile conspiracy, their implemented plot to suppress the great soul, to squelch all his dreams which he intends to manifest in reality.

 

These enemies of the great soul gain an immense feeling of satisfaction and pleasure in thwarting his plans, his attempt to share his views with the world. If they can defeat him or kill him, that is final victory, they assume. If they poison his name with the public, telling lies, slandering, and defaming him, they can turn public opinion against him. If they can keep him silenced, deplatformed, unknown, without supporters, kept on the fringes of society, in anonymous obscurity, this collective campaign of malice and opposition fills them with great glee.

 

These living devils, this pack of mediocrities and nonindividuators, have denied themselves, their children and society, the benefits of the great soul’s creative works, of his new ideas, of his moral excellence. The next generation is deprived of the new that is true, good, and beautiful. The wicked opposition to the great soul, engineered by these joiners, is a tangible expression of their nihilism and hatred. They have power but their triumph is intruding the life of lies upon humanity, and their wasteful scheme makes the world a much poorer place.

 

They have extended and prolonged the reign of the Evil Spirits on earth. They, in their willful blindness, their ignorance, and their clear comprehension of what they have devised, refer to each other as normal, virtuous, righteous people that serve God, though they serve only Satan.

 

The great soul is inferior, evil, and stupid: he is the current Jew to be pogrommed.

 

This is rationalized, Luficerian pride, collective, false, and vicious, nakedly, openly paraded about and celebrated in society.

 

This is victorious altruism at work in society (victorious for a while only); this is the raw display and assertion of brutal tyranny, the mob power of powerlessness, where the selfless minions of the demons shout with joy that they have a power and narrative say on earth, as the great soul has been successfully defeated, demonized, marginalized and silenced.

 

They can for a few years, hold the great spirit, the godly goodness and new ideas which he exemplifies and artistically fabricates as works of art which he presents to the world for its edification, but the day of reckoning will descend. God will bring justice to earth, and the great soul, who has been crying out to God for assistance, will be heard, and divine justice in this world and in the next will be visited upon the altruistic evildoers, the children of darkness currently holding sway on earth.

Tuesday, September 17, 2024

Uncondtional Love

 

Dennis Prager is one of the wisest Americans alive today. There is no doubt that this pious Jew gains some of his wisdom from his Jewish culture, a mixture of otherworldliness and common-sense worldly enjoyment and involvement, that more extreme Christians should adopt.

 

One of his profound insights concern the concept of unconditional love. He is against it. Now, let me hasten to say where someone gives or receives unconditional love, great, enjoy giving it or receiving it.

 

Young people today are not having children, because these young adults are seeking unconditional love, which children often do not reciprocate; Prager notes these young people are getting dogs who give unconditional love. He argues that this is a regrettable mistake being made by young people.

 

Yes, kids give conditional love and sometimes no love, but having kids is the greatest blessing in the world, a most rich, meaningful, personal adventure. I agree.

 

I wonder if love is a feeling or a rational orientation towards another human being? I think mature love is perhaps more a rational orientation towards another, more than it is a sentimental or passionate orientation to another, though it is both, and these two loving orientations towards another human are inseparable from one another. They need not clash when one loves another: one can think about one that one loves rationally, as well as feelingly.

 

This is where Prager’s concept of conditional love fits in. It is better to love God, others, and oneself rationally or conditionally, more than passionately or unconditionally. And it is better to love God, others, or oneself more than to hate or be indifferent when loving.

 

We are complex creatures, for whomever is the target of our love, is also a target of our hate or ill will. Such conflicting orientations likely are universal, real, and predictable. Feelings of unconditional love are often too melodramatic, reversible and temporary.

 

Thus, it is prudent to love or hate conditionally rather than to love or hate another or oneself unconditionally. It can be evil to love anyone or to hate anyone unconditionally for it is immoderate. To love and hate unconditionally is, in the long run, generally to be hating more than loving.

 

To love and hate anyone conditionally often is more loving in the long run, because extreme orientation towards God, others and oneself is unhealthy and induces much needless pain and suffering in the relationship.

 

Thus, having children will be rewarding for those that love the child for who he is, whether he freely, unconditionally loves his parents back or not. It might be better that the youngster become a good person, well-trained and civilized by his parents, rather than parents worrying about being popular, being the unconditionally liked or loved parents, though being liked, or loved is always nice to receive. Conditional love is more mature, more steadfast, more substantial. It is more lasting.

 

To expect unconditional love from a child is an unrealistic expectation for a parent to assume. They are separate people, and one must find validation for happiness by one’ own individuating as a lived gift sent back to one’s creators.

 

To expect unconditional love from a child or anyone is an unfair imposition extended from the parent to the child.

Sunday, September 15, 2024

The Golden Rule Revisited

 

The basic moral message behind the Golden Rule is that one treats others as how one treats oneself, or bow one wants to be treated. This suggestion seems both reasonable and plausible.

 

If we would be a good person, we should have love ourselves more than we do not, and we would self-realize more than just exist without artistic ambition. Then, if one is well on the way to becoming an artistic individuator, then one could feel proper pride in one’s personal effort and outcome, and yet be humble, knowing that the self is mortal, flawed and limited, accepting that in comparison to the creative talent demonstrated by a good deity that we follow, our comparative efforts, though  meaningful and impressive, fall far short of what our divine friend has achieved, and this is proper humility to state the obvious openly.

 

It would seem then that we should esteem others more than we would try to humble them, and we also should be objective and impartial in how we judge their actions and character, and that will influence how we esteem or respect them or not, and we should still generally treat people with affection and respect, as that is how we should want to be treated in return.

 

If we are good persons and are individuating, we should still be more proud than humble, but mostly we should act modestly with courtesy towards ourselves, others and the good deities. We should be more logical and emotional in our interactions with others, neither too theatrical, too emotional, nor catatonic or without affect.

 

We can be as ambitious for good as we want to be, but we should not be haughty in our relations with others, for that is bad form.  We should give most but not all glory to God.

Always There

 

I well know the myth of Adam and Eve as our first parents, in the Garden of Eden, and completely good and innocent. But, that does not seem realistic to me. I think they were always born evil, and they were born with free will, and could choose to do evil if they wanted to, which is why Yahweh felt the prime need to warn them not to eat the forbidden fruit, because God knew they had the capacity to sin, and the will to choose to sin, so, it was likely sooner or later that they would eat the forbidden fruit.

 

The First human coupe innate knowledge of good and evil from the start.